Where have all the dual WAN routers gone?

Draytek Vigor 2910g dual WAN routerLast week’s internet failure in my home has made it very clear to me that I need a backup. Even my wife, who frequently works from home using Citrix, had a lot of trouble getting anything done. We really need to be online all the time. So the first thing I did was sign up for a second home broadband line. I’ll soon have both a cable and a ADSL(2+) connection. Now all I need to do is tie them together.

I thought about getting a second router, and putting up a second wifi network for the new connection. But that would mean I’d probably end up interfering with my current signal, and it’s not really an elegant solution. So I started looking into dual WAN routers. These routers accept two ‘inputs’, and allow you to route your traffic between the two using a set of user-defined rules (“torrents go left, email goes right”). What you end up with is a single LAN that uses both connections simultaneously. No need to switch networks when one goes offline, your router will do that for you.

Draytek only?

Almost all the dual WAN routers aimed at consumers and small businesses seem to have been discontinued. I was only able to find a couple of models by Draytek. Googling turned up other models by Linksys, 3com, Netgear and others, but all of them are no longer listed on their respective manufacturer’s websites. Most of the reviews and forum posts Google turned up were from 2007 or even older. Most of them were quite positive about the various products though.

So, am I wrong in thinking that these routers are really nifty, and would be ideal for my setup? Or is their disappearance a sign I should stay away from this type of solution? Or perhaps these routers simply turned out to be too expensive for consumers and sold poorly?

Related posts:
  1. Wireless routers explained
  2. How to easily set up a redundant internet connection
  3. Tell Chrome who you are!
  4. Quick tip: Atheros AR5007 wifi and Linksys routers
  5. Linksys E4200 impressions

65 Comments

  1. In our office we currently have two different connections, ADSL and a cable modem. We want to set up the network so that all VPN traffic is being routed via the DSL and all HTTP or other internet traffic is routed via the cable modem. Can anyone recommend a quality dual wan router, or otherwise? Currently we are running only off the ADSL.

    Reply Comment by Harri — October 19, 2011 @ 10:48 pm

  2. You can do this quite easily with PFSense: http://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/Multi_WAN_/_Load_Balancing
    You will need to roll out an x86 computer with PFSense router in the first place though. There are plenty of guides on the PFSense website on how to do this.

    Reply Comment by James Pearce — November 13, 2011 @ 7:12 am

    • OKay, but that would require a pull-blown PC to be on 24/7, sucking up 10-20 times the power a good router does? Not to mention that it doesn’t quite fit on the shelf where I currently have my modem. etc set up… :)

      Reply Comment by Roy — November 21, 2011 @ 11:52 am

      • Foxconn SFF… 130-200 to build and uses 20(ish) watts power… attach 2 2tb drives and a multi nic card , load balancing software and you have a multi-wan gateway, and home server….

        setup… 2 in from wan… 1 out to router wan… 1 out to router lan (for filesharing)

        Reply Comment by kdrac21 — December 8, 2011 @ 12:15 pm

Leave a Reply